I don’t think I agree with this. The open teams I’ve been on the past 5 years have generally been about half senior aged athletes and half athletes that have aged out. Obviously there are gyms where that’s not the case but when I’m at competitions a lot of the people on the other teams definitely look old enough to vote.
Regardless I don’t really care about wether or not gyms field open teams. What I care about is adults and minors intermingling. It Makes it was too easy for predatory people to start to build relationships with minors that don’t draw attention. Every open team I’ve been on has had a team snap chat group chat for taking about hair, meeting times, sharing videos, etc and every season I refuse a dozen add requests from high school or even middle school aged children. It’s unacceptable.
It’s how people like Jerry get access to children.
Adults and minors should not be on a team together. Not enough adults for a full team? Don’t field the team. I don’t care.
Adults and minors are together on all Senior teams, not just Open teams, since 18-19 year olds are technically adults. I get what you’re saying, but I just don’t think there are enough 30+ year olds on Open teams that they’re going to revolve the rules around them. People that old might be coaches at the gym too, so whether they are athletes themselves or coaches, adults and kids will be interacting and have access to each other.
At least at the gyms I’ve been at, there hasn’t been a ton of mingling at practices; you’re there to work and perform cheerleading skills. The younger kids tend to interact with younger kids, and the older athletes tend to interact with people more their age (sometimes they take on a protective/older sibling type role towards the younger ones too). Beyond that, it’s up to parents to make sure their 13 year olds aren’t in group chats or hanging out with grown men outside of practice.
Jerry preyed on kids from different gyms while at competitions. As an athlete in a sport full of minors, he had plenty of access to kids whether or not they were directly on a team with him.
There are 16 year olds who look 20, so it’s hard to know the age of teams just by looking at them. I’m familiar with the makeup of a few Open teams and they are mostly Sr age eligible with a few aged out kids, but I’m sure there are also plenty teams that are more half & half as you mentioned. The gyms affiliated with colleges like GymTyme I’m sure have more aged out college athletes than a typical Open team. I assume International Open teams have more aged out athletes than Senior Open as well.
Gyms have to be able to form competitive teams that can handle all the difficulty, not every gym has 16+ year old flyers growing on trees. It’s easy to say just don’t form teams then and turn athletes away, but gyms are in business to form competitive teams. The Open divisions are so popular these days, they’re obviously filling a need that gyms have. The wider age range gives them better flexibility to form teams.