I look for key qualities that I believe my captains need such as:
Leadership (who can motivate the team, have a great attitude and be a role model....in school AND outside school)
Responsibility (are they on time with what they need to have/where they need to be, can I count on them to get tasks done)
Communication Skills (can they keep the peace, keep every teammate in the loop, not too shy for confrontation/decision making skills)
Work Ethic (always giving 110%, never giving up)
and then take those in to account when deciding between candidates. The girls have to fill out a packet that is somewhat like a job application, requiring a letter of rec from a teacher, their GPA, grade, cheerleading experience, and then some short answers about themselves such as : why do you want to be captain, what do you think are the captain's responsibilities, what are some ideas you have for next year, etc............. Then there is also an interview with each candidate done similar to a job interview ( I think the more practice they get with interviewing/applications, the better prepared they will be for college and beyond).
For the interview, we ask questions more geared towards how they would handle situations and also include a fun one that throws some of them off guard. Examples:
-If you were an appliance/color/animal/season, what would you be and why (requires creative thinking and the kids never expect the question).
-What is your definition of leadership?
-What do you think your biggest challenge would be as captain? How would you overcome it?
-How can cheerleaders’ best represent their school and student body?
-How would you handle a situation such as (pick one or two):
1.) A teammate tells you to shut up, or rolls her eyes at you during a practice.
2.) Two members get into an argument in front of the team.
3.) A squad member is acting innappropriately at a game.
4.) Several girls are talking excessively during practice and it is disruptive.
5.) The Coach makes an unpopular decision even you disagree with.
6.) A teammate is calling chants when they aren't supposed to be.