All-Star Top Teams - Opinion

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mar 25, 2010
2,116
10,033
570
33
Minnesota
www.facebook.com
I am a(n)...
Coach
Brandon Senior Black
California Allstars Large Coed
California Allstars Smoed
California Allstars Lady Bullets
Cheer Athletics Panthers
Cheer Extreme Senior Elite
Cheer Extreme SSX
Gymtyme Pink
Gymtyme Black Smack
Maryland Twisters F5
Stingray Orange
Stingray Smoke
Twist and Shout Obsession
Top Gun Large Coed
Woodlands Elite Generals
 
Aug 21, 2010
482
550
41
31
Maine
I am a(n)...
Retired From Cheer
In no particular order

World Cup shooting stars
CA panthers
CA cheetahs
CA wildcats
Cali smoed
Cea senior elite
Brandon senior black
Top gun large coed
Top gun oo5
Stingrays orange
ECE fame
CJA small all girl
Cali aces
Maryland twisters f5
Top gun lady jags




The Fierce Board App! || iPhone || Android || Upgrade Your Account!
 
  • Like
Reactions: jaiho

luv2cheer92

Staff member
FBOD:LLFB
Mar 15, 2011
9,242
15,320
1
29
DFW
totalcheerperformance.com
I am a(n)...
Athlete
So I decided to look at this more objectively and calculated scores for the top teams. Using a scale that included giving more points towards more recent wins, I gave the following:
pre 2010: NCA Win= 3 pts. Worlds- 1st= 3 pts, 2nd= 2 pts, 3rd= 1 pt
2010-now: NCA Win= 6 pts. Worlds- 1st= 6 pts, 2nd= 4 pts, 3rd= 2pts, essentially doubling the points. It was hard to determine what to use so for some teams I used the name and some I used the division. In order the results were:
1. Stingray Orange (small senior/med senior) = 61 points
2. Spirit of Texas Coed (limited/med coed) = 52 points
3. Cheer Athletics Large Senior (Supercats/Panthers)= 44 (if you add in Panthers 2011 and 2012 = 56 points)
4. Top Gun Large Coed (added semi limited 2011)= 43 points
5. World Cup Shooting Stars = 42 points
6. TIE Cheer Athletics Large Coed (Wildcats/Cheetahs)= 34 points
6. TIE California Allstars Large Coed = 34 points
8. Twist and Shout Coed (limited/med coed)= 32 points
9. Maryland Twisters F5 = 29 points
10. California Allstars Smoed= 28 points
11. Georgia Allstars Coed (large coed/med coed) = 27 points
12. TIE Cheer Extreme Senior Elite= 24 points
12. TIE California Allstars Lady Bullets = 24 points
14. Brandon Senior Black= 23 points
15. TIE Stingray Smoke= 18 points
15. TIE Gymtyme Coed (Black/Platinum)= 18 points
16. ACE Warriors (large coed/limited coed/semi-limited)= 17 points
17. Cheer Extreme Coed Elite= 16 points
18. Cheer Extreme SSX= 12 points
19. Tribe Chiefs= 11 points
20. Rockstar Small Coed (Rolling Stones/Beatles)= 8 points
21. Woodlands Elite Generals= 7 points
Now this is definitely not perfect, but it gives you a pretty good idea on where everyone stands.
ETA: This is just senior teams, if someone wants me to do open teams I will.
 
Jul 23, 2012
793
2,735
1
I am a(n)...
Coach
So I decided to look at this more objectively and calculated scores for the top teams. Using a scale that included giving more points towards more recent wins, I gave the following:
pre 2010: NCA Win= 3 pts. Worlds- 1st= 3 pts, 2nd= 2 pts, 3rd= 1 pt
2010-now: NCA Win= 6 pts. Worlds- 1st= 6 pts, 2nd= 4 pts, 3rd= 2pts, essentially doubling the points. It was hard to determine what to use so for some teams I used the name and some I used the division. In order the results were:
1. Stingray Orange (small senior/med senior) = 61 points
2. Spirit of Texas Coed (limited/med coed) = 52 points
3. Cheer Athletics Large Senior (Supercats/Panthers)= 44 (if you add in Panthers 2011 and 2012 = 56 points)
4. Top Gun Large Coed (added semi limited 2011)= 43 points
5. World Cup Shooting Stars = 42 points
6. TIE Cheer Athletics Large Coed (Wildcats/Cheetahs)= 34 points
6. TIE California Allstars Large Coed = 34 points
8. Twist and Shout Coed (limited/med coed)= 32 points
9. Maryland Twisters F5 = 29 points
10. California Allstars Smoed= 28 points
11. Georgia Allstars Coed (large coed/med coed) = 27 points
12. TIE Cheer Extreme Senior Elite= 24 points
12. TIE California Allstars Lady Bullets = 24 points
14. Brandon Senior Black= 23 points
15. TIE Stingray Smoke= 18 points
15. TIE Gymtyme Coed (Black/Platinum)= 18 points
16. ACE Warriors (large coed/limited coed/semi-limited)= 17 points
17. Cheer Extreme Coed Elite= 16 points
18. Cheer Extreme SSX= 12 points
19. Tribe Chiefs= 11 points
20. Rockstar Small Coed (Rolling Stones/Beatles)= 8 points
21. Woodlands Elite Generals= 7 points
Now this is definitely not perfect, but it gives you a pretty good idea on where everyone stands.
ETA: This is just senior teams, if someone wants me to do open teams I will.


Very interesting! I like the approach you took to this. Thanks for posting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CEAisstronger

F!ERCE

Cheer Parent
Mar 23, 2010
2,596
3,544
5,151
Duke! Durham, NC
I am a(n)...
Retired From Cheer
Some "absences" on people's lists are just silly lol there are some teams that you couldn't possibly truly believe don't belong in the Top 15. Panthers come to mind.

Anyway, mine would probably be...

ACE Warriors
Brandon Black
Cali Coed
Cali Small Senior
Cali Smoed
Cheer Athletics Panthers (or "Supercats")
Cheer Athletics Senior Coed (Wildcats/Cheetahs, whichever was in senior coed in any respective year)
Cheer Extreme Senior Elite
Cheer Extreme SSX
Maryland Twisters F5
SOT Coed
Stingrays Orange
T&S Coed
Top Gun Coed
World Cup Shooting Stars

CEA Coed Elite, WE Generals and GA Coed are others that come close, but are, IMO, not quite as sure to be an absolutely knockout year after year.

I like your breakdown @luv2cheer92. I think if I were going to do something similar, I would probably give a little less weight to an NCA win (or add points for medaling at NCA), but I do like how you did it, too. That must have taken 100 years...lol.

Using a slightly different scale (Worlds Only, I don't have NCA results in front of me):

2008 & Earlier: Worlds - 1st, 3 pts. 2nd, 2 pts. 3rd, 1 pt.
2009-Present: Worlds - 1st, 6 pts, 2nd 4.5 pts, 3rd 3 pts.

1. SOT Coed - 39
2. Rays Orange - 35
3. Panthers/Supercats - 34
4. TGLC - 31
5. TIE - CEA Senior Elite - 27
5. TIE - WCSS - 27
7. Cali Coed - 23
8. TIE T&S Senior Coed - 22.5
8. TIE Cheer Athletics Senior Coed - 22.5 (37.5 if you count Wildcats for the years there was no senior coed team, which would put them in 2nd)
10. Brandon Black - 21
11. Cali Small Senior - 20
12. Maryland Twisters F5 - 17.5
13. TIE Cali Smoed - 16.5
13. TIE CEA SSX - 16.5
15. TIE ACE Warriors - 13.5
15. TIE CEA Coed Elite - 13.5
17. Rockstar Small Coed - 10.5
18. Georgia Coed - 9
19. Rays Senior Coed (Smoke/Purple) - 7.5
20. WE Generals - 6
21. Tribe Chiefs - 4.5

It is worthwhile to note that some of these teams accumulated these points over far fewer seasons than others. For instance, Smoed has only been at Worlds since 2011 and already has more points (on this scale) than other teams who have been attending for many, many years.

Weirdly I wrote my list before I calculated these points and my top 15 were the top 15 here, too. Haha strange. Guess I only think about Worlds! Lol
 

Ems

Jun 17, 2012
1,504
2,109
1
Denver
I am a(n)...
Retired From Cheer
In alphabetical order by gym, using the division/team name they are currently in:
ACE Warriors
Brandon Senior Black
California Coed
California Lady Bullets
California Smoed
Cheer Athletics Panthers
Cheer Extreme Senior Elite
Cheer Extreme SSX
Gymtyme Black Smack
Gymtyme Pink Ladies
Spirit of Texas Medium Coed
Stingrays Orange
Top Gun Large Coed
Top Gun OO5 (IOC5)
World Cup Shooting Stars


The Fierce Board App! || iPhone
 
Jul 18, 2010
185
370
40
New York
I am a(n)...
Athlete
Ace Warriors
Brandon Senior Black
California Large Coed
California Lady Bullets
Cheer Athletics Panthers
Cheer Athletics Wildcats
Cheer Extreme Senior Elite
Gym Tyme Pink
Maryland Twisters F5
Spirit of Texas medium coed
Stingray Orange
Top Gun Large Coed
Top Gun IOC5
Twist and Shout Obsession
World Cup Shooting Stars

This takes into account how successful the teams have been for the last 10 years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jaiho
Feb 21, 2012
256
380
1
I am a(n)...
Athlete
Brandon Senior Black
California Allstars -Cali coed
California Allstars Lady Bullets
Cheer athletics Wildcats
Cheer Extreme Coed Elite
Green Bay Elite Lime
Gym Tyme Black
Maryland Twisters F5
Maryland twisters reign
Top Gun Large coed
Top Gun OO5
Twist and shout Obsession
Spirit of Texas Medium Coed
Stingrays allstars Orange
World Cup Shooting Stars
 
  • Like
Reactions: jaiho
May 27, 2013
6
2
1
NY, NY
I am a(n)...
Fan
CEA Senior Elite
CEA Small Senior X
California Allstars Coed
Top Gun Lady Jags
World Cup Shooting Stars
California Lady Bullets
Top Gun LS Coed
CEA Coed Elite
Cali Smoed
Cheer Athletics Aces
Brandon Senior Black
Twist & Shout (Obsession and Genesis)
CJA

I hope I didn't forget any..
 
Apr 12, 2013
204
192
1
Georgia
I am a(n)...
Athlete
Cheer Athletics Panthers
Cheer Athletics Cheetahs
Cheer Athletics Wildcats
Cali Coed
Cali Lady Bullets
Cali Smoed
Stingray Allstars Orange
Top Gun Large Coed
Maryland Twisters F5
Cheer Extreme Senior Elite
Green Bay Elite Lime
World Cup Shooting Stars
Spirit of Texas Med Coed
Brandon Senior Black
ACE Warriors

These just came to mind in no particular order.. (Orange is my favorite though :p)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Staff online

  • JBS
    Admin / Gymnastics Coach

Members online