I know some of the kids on my daughters team could tumble with world level tumbling but MOST could not. Other gyms field teams of kids that most can do world level tumbling and only a FEW cannot. Not sure each gym's philosophy on how and why they formed NT teams or why a team that possesses the necessary tumbling for worlds level would choose NT instead. I just know kiddo's team was formed with the idea of retaining those senior age athletes as suggested in the IASF explanation. My kiddo, reached r5 level in her tumbling but couldn't break into elite world level tumbling, no double, no standing full, or special combos. She was so grateful for a chance to finally go to worlds on an NT team. Otherwise she would never have gone, and now she's retired. Now that NT has blown up this season, I truly hope teams are made of athletes that now have a chance to go to worlds because they dont possess the needed tumbling or struggle with mental blocks, not teams full of world level tumblers hoping for an easy win. Granted, even if a team is made up of tumblers, the argument can be made that they dont tumble so what's the difference? I guess I think athletes and teams need to be level appropriate according to their skills as a whole. Like not placing level 5 athletes on a level 2 team. It's weird to me to see people with doubles and standing fulls, and toe touch fulls on a NT team because it seems like their skills are not being used to the athlete's advantage, like they are being shortchanged a little. But that's just my opinion lol.
It will definitely not be easy this season. The division is huge this season. I know for coed NT this last season, there were more than 21 teams in the US alone with 18 going to worlds and only 3 going on to finals. I think overall there were a total of 33 or 35 at worlds all together and I know of some coed non US teams who didnt get a bid to worlds. There are gonna be waaaay more than 20 US teams this season. I forgot the number of all girl but it was a bit less than coed but it is also exploding.
I couldn't agree more with everything you said !
For my kiddo, last year was her 1st Worlds and she fits the description you made of having some tumbling but not elite level, being on the verge of retiring, getting a chance at a Worlds team because of NT and so on and so forth.
Her team was mainly composed of level 3's and 4.2's with zero Worlds experience (27 out of 32 were rookies) and I think like most other teams in this division, they were thrown together and the gym owners crossed their fingers that it could work without having any comparison to go by.
Without being a dream team, they did pretty well all season, ending it with a Silver Globe just behind Cheer Extreme Lady Lux who were the exact opposite of them (Around 5-6 rookies out of 30+ girls).
That said, you could see the gap between the 3 or 4 best teams in the world and the rest of the bunch, it was pretty obvious that every gym didn't go at it the same way when they put together their teams, again, they couldn't know what to look for because they had nothing to compare with.
Now this year is much different ! Everybody knows what to look for and it shows...Like you said, the division exploded in co-ed AND All-Girl, there's not a day that goes by without learning that this or that gym now has a NT team, from Cali to Brandon and every other big time gym !
Last night we had our team reveal and kiddo is on the same team as last year, with the difference that they are now composed mostly of last year's level 5 athletes and more experienced girls, and yes, some of them do have tumbling skills to go to Worlds on other levels but for some reason (My guess is that other teams with tumbling were fully loaded or they wanted to give their bodies a break from tumbling, I really don't know...) ended up on the 6.0 team.
Yes, this year US teams will be scary good but thanks to the International rule of 3 teams per country, it will be anybody's ball game once on the Worlds mat on day 2, can't wait to see how it unfolds !
Wish everyone, athletes, parents and coaches a great year on their 2019-2020 team !!