I've had an opportunity to be a part of both worlds. I prefer All Stars 100%, but I would never take anything away from Pop Warner cheerleading. Unlike All Stars, there is only ONE National Championship that Pop Warner teams go to every year. (So when a Pop Warner team says they're National Champions, that means a LOT.) Also, Pop Warner teams only have TWO MONTHS to learn to build skills with one another, learn a routine, and perfect it before their first competition. (Whereas AS teams usually start in May and have until November to get it together.) Also, it should be noted that PW has a limit on how many hours/days a week the girls can practice. And one more thing to add: PW does not use a spring floor at any of their official events; those girls are stunting, tumbling, and jumping on regular ol' foam mats. I give them a LOT of credit.