No, I get what you're saying... However, my point is there are kids that are trying to get PE credit for band (In high school b/c it's a class... ( Right now they get a "music education/arts" credit I believe) ... In reality, most of this kids still need the physical education...Then others are trying to get PE credits for athletics by making them into a CLASS... This does not resolve the increased required credit issue AND it takes up an academic or elective class period. I agree with the one poster who said there should be a way to log hours of physical activity. Once you have reached a certain amount then and only then can you receive appropriated credits. I also understand that many people don't "like" PE or what activity PE has to offer...but its kind of PART of your core curriculum. While many kids are very hard working and do numerous activities in and out of school... Many do not. PE was put in place to keep kids well rounded.. Introduce them to sports they might not "know" about... Get them out of the classroom and "doing" something. Is it something that needs to be worked on, yes... But do I envy the job of a PE teacher, No. I can only explain it this way: when you go to school you have to learn MATH... Core math. You don't get your choice of choosing math as it applies to accounting, math as it applies to computer programming or math as it applies to engineering... Until later in college. (This isn't done in high schools simply b/c kids don't have a clear vision of what EXACTLY they will go into profession wise until AFTER being offered a little bit of everything) It's math, and we can't add a class for those involved in the "math club"... Then give them appropriate school credit because they are expanding on it in a way they like. How is anyone to know they received a "proper" expansion on the subject. (Now I'm on a tangent) ...
Bottom line, there will never be enough hours in the day for the people who work their butts off...no matter what way you try to make it work. And there will always be too many for those who simply do not care.