Thank you all so much for your input. I'm taking every little tidbit in to help with our decision. We actually lived in Indy for 2 years about 9 years ago. My oldest daughter was born in Noblesville and we lived in Carmel before that. We did like it back then, but we are in such a different place in our lives now. If it was just us no big deal, but taking the kids out of their comfort zone (when we really sold them on Cinci as their home town) is eating me up. We are struggling to find the area we want to be in that has the right combo of good schools, homes we like, good proximity to the gym we choose, good proximity to retail, etc. Sometime soon I'm hoping I can look back and wonder why I was so worried about it all :)