My varsity shoes after football season, 2 privates a week, 2 comps, and half of basketball season. Not pretty, but still together. They are a lot looser than when I got them though, and they
feel worn down. The toes are really bad (we have to do a BHS after every cheer, and I step out so I hit my toes a lot) but the rest of it is okay... Maybe it depends on the style of the shoe? All of ours are holding up, they just don't look good. You can clean the leather, but the dirt gets stuck in the seams and the creases and makes them look really dirty.
For comparison:
My nikes after 2 seasons. They hold up well and are easy to clean. I don't particularly like them, but at least they're durable! (They're dirty right now but if I took a clorox wipe to them they'd practically look new)
ETA: Sorry about the size! I thought since I took them on my phone they would be small. But apparently not! :oops: