One more question :)
Is it normal to add practices to the schedule with only a few days’ notice?
We have 3 kids they all have activities and competitions we schedule everything out months ahead of time. My CP was told she had an extra practice with only a few day notice and was told if she didn’t go she would not be allowed to compete. She had to choose between going to practice, or supporting her bother in his event that was scheduled months earlier and miss a practice. This caused a lot of family consternation and hurt feelings over a 2.5 hr practice. She is in the gym 15-18hrs a week as it is I didn’t see how 2.5hr more would make a difference. She went to the practice and miss her brothers JROTC awards sermon. He was the event MC and was promoted to Chief of Staff so it was a big deal for him
Yes, this is common. If someone is injured, if a stunt isn't hitting, if a kid is sick, the routine may need to be reworked.
In cheer, teams do not learn one routine and then keep it throughout the entire season. As the season progresses, the routine is tweaked and difficulty is added as the athletes progress in their individual and team skills. I think you need to ask yourself a question... Do you want your child to participate in a sport for the recreation or for the competition? You seemed upset that your daughter's team won the first couple competitions but was in the bottom of placings for the last two. Something for you to think about: Say a stunt in your CP's routine isn't hitting and will cause a major deduction at a competition if it doesn't hit there. The team calls for an extra practice to fix or rework this stunt. This extra practice could be the difference between being in last place or the middle of the placings, or the middle of the placings and first place because the cause of a potential deduction was removed from the routine. This has happened to my CP's team, except their pyramid went perfectly at every single practice but fell at the first two competitions. The deduction they received was the difference between placing 1st/2nd and 4th at a competition. I would have much rather had an extra practice before the last competition to make sure that pyramid was solid, even if it meant sacrificing time with my family who was visiting from out of town. If you would rather your CP be on a team or at a gym that sticks to only its scheduled practices and allows you to vacation at destination competitions, then you probably just need to find a new gym, not a new sport. But you have to understand that sometimes the extra practices make huge differences when it comes to how successful a team is.
As far as the hair and makeup go, is the coach really threatening to kick kids off or not let kids compete if their hair and makeup aren't perfect? Or perhaps is this pre-teen angst? I overheard her coach threaten a kid one time with not being allowed to compete because she didn't show up ready for the second time in a row. But it had nothing to do with perfectionism, this kid showed up with straight hair (when it was supposed to be curly) and not a bit of makeup on her face 15 minutes before warm-ups. Because of this one kid constantly being late, her entire team had to check-in 30 minutes earlier than any of the other teams. My CP is 8 (also on a Y2 team) and freaks out if her hair and makeup isn't perfect. But she is a perfectionist. Another thing to consider is that this is a team sport. So while it may not directly affect the team's score if your daughter doesn't do her hair and makeup the way the coach asks her to, if the rest of the team is putting in that effort, so should she.
But if the coaches are really being this negative and difficult, then perhaps you need to change gyms. I would question the coaches' judgment if they are allowing 11 year-olds to do level 6 stunts. ETA: I just re-read your post and saw that she is working on 2-man level 6 stunts with a coach. Carry on.
Or perhaps team sports are just not a good fit for your family and your daughter should go back to gymnastics. I found the parents, coaches, and some of the athletes to be far worse in gymnastics than in cheer. That is why my daughter is no longer doing gymnastics. But to each their own.