Thanks for the info about Komova. I wasn't aware she was back at competitions at all. I hope she makes a big of a comeback as she can. I feel the same about Aly, Gabby and potentially even Maroney that you do about her. I think they hit their peaks in 2012 and a full comeback to Olympic strength after over two years off seems slim. Of course, I hope they prove me wrong. But that, coupled with the talented juniors aging in will make a second Olympics a pretty tall task for any of them.
I can't argue that Komova wasn't the best all around in 2012 but she didn't come through in the clutch. Gabby did, and I'm not sure that was just luck. Same with Maroney's vault. I don't necessarily think she was unlucky, I think she made a conscious decision to put an exclamation point on her vault but sat it down instead.
I can definitely see that with Mustafina though. It's easy to see why the younger Russian girls look up to her. I was ok with her floor bronze at first, but the more I rewatch it the more I'm starting to think that should have gone to Skinner. She probably was favored a little for her name and for her more "artistic" style (which the judges love to see I'm sure) but the big difference to me was in difficulty and landings, and Skinner clearly had the edge in both of those categories.