Ohhhh! I could have used a thread like this when I was racking my brain trying to come upp with awards for all of my tinys last season. I tend to stay away from using 'best' in the title. Yes, it's hard when trying to come up with so many awards, but telling one girl she has better jumps than everybody else makes the rest of the team feel bad. I like
@Lesia Rathje 's Rockstar, Determination, & Trendsetter ideas!
Here are some of mine, I'm sorry if they're too juvenile for your team. i included the concept with the name of the award, so maybe that'll help if the title doesn't. I just had to do awards for 6 year olds.
Mini Megaphone (You can always drop "mini" & make it the megaphone award for the loudest)
Head in the Game Award (for the girl who pays attention to what's going on out on the field/court)
Perfect Attendance
Warrior (someone who is able to fall down & brush it off)
Fashionista (crazy-in-a-good-way/high fashion, fun makeup)
Picasso/ [insert famous artist's name here, could even be beloved art teacher at school] Award (this one's for the cheerleader who's first in line to help with the banner and her fellow squad's faces on game day)
Forever Stamp (something that has to do with the mail or distance that's cheesy, maybe it's the see you later award, or the don't forget to write award, i don't know. Here's the idea. Since it's high school, i'm guessing some of these kids are seniors. This award can go to the athlete who is traveling the farthest away for college.) That last one was horrible, I know, this is why I make awards for children. Anyway, best of luck!!!!!!!