Just for clarity's sake; Varsity DOES pay the inexpensive competition license to ASCAP and BMI. That's not the issue. The issue is Derivative Works (aka remixes) of copyrighted music; and this is where things get into a gray area very quickly. There is no such thing as a blanket license for remixes; every single remix ever created technically needs to get cleared (and paid for) from each of the artists involved. This has much more to do with mechanical rights, which are not granted in all instances, even at any price. For instance, Foo Fighters does not allow their music be used on SYTYCD. Normally mechanical rights are only a concern in broadcast situations; otherwise the generic competition license covers use in civic centers, auditoriums, etc. What is new with Varsity is interpreting the laws such that the broadcast rules seems to apply everywhere and in all situations.