How many athletes (on average) do you have age out a year?
And for those that age out but stay relatively close (especially ones that have grown up/spent many years with the program), do you encourage them to at least take one year off and experience college without super senior-ing (or immersing themselves more in collegiate cheer)?
It popped into my head this year with some of the athletes that I've always loved watching on your teams and seeing them talk about "being their last practice as a CA athlete/last worlds/etc". I'm definitely going to miss seeing some of their personalities/abilities on the floor.
I don't believe there is a single one-size-fits-all answer for every individual regarding formal education. Some young adults absolutely need to eliminate all of their extra-curriculars and spend every free moment studying. Others may benefit more from what they do outside of a lecture hall. The "right" blend is going to be different for every person depending on their goals, strengths, and personalities.
I did pretty well academically, but what I learned through sports, cheer, and extra-curriculars helped me FAR more than what I learned directly from textbooks or teachers standing at blackboards. You learn valuable lessons from sports and non-traditional activities that help enrich your overall learning experience. Football, cheer, track, gymnastics, theater, etc. are not replacements for sitting in a classroom, but they certainly add to the overall fabric of your education.
College cheer can be a fantastic experience, but it isn't automatically "better" than all star. (Same for high school cheer.) In most places they are very different experiences from each other. I love all star for many reasons and I don't think that it magically quits being useful/fun/worthy when someone hands you a diploma.
We have talked some people out of staying around for a super-senior year, and others we have helped convince their parents that staying around and going to a local college was a good idea. (For a few, that was the only way they were willing to set foot in any college.) It depends on the athlete and the situation.